San Marcos Mercury | Local News from San Marcos and Hays County, Texas
Email Email | Print Print --

December 20th, 2011
Freethought San Marcos: A humanist looks at Christmas

Freethought San Marcos: A column
by LAMAR W. HANKINS

Robert Green Ingersoll is one of the least known orators of the 19th century, yet he lectured six or seven times a week from the Civil War until his death in 1899. He was vastly influential and campaigned vigorously for every Republican elected President in those years. He has been largely forgotten by history because he was a secular humanist, dubbed “The Great Agnostic” by friends and foes alike. His father was an abolitionist Presbyterian preacher. Ingersoll fought in the Civil War and greatly admired President Abraham Lincoln.

While Ingersoll was a lawyer by profession, he earned a good income from his mostly sold-out lectures for which people were charged $7 to $14 per person in today’s money. Much of this income he gave to charitable causes. Ingersoll had a photographic memory, which made it possible for him to memorize all of his lectures. A complete set of his written works and lectures were published in 12 volumes and are now available on CD.

Ingersoll’s life was summarized by Herman E. Kittredge: “He became the terror of the pulpit, reviled by the clergy, slandered by the religious media, and yet the friend of presidents, and the friend of great men and women such as Thomas Edison, Andrew Carnegie, Mark Twain and Elizabeth Cady Stanton. Known as the ‘American Infidel,’ he went on to become the first Attorney General of the State of Illinois.” And Ingersoll was a great influence on Clarence Darrow three decades before the Scopes Trial.

Ingersoll was a good friend of Walt Whitman, who considered Ingersoll the greatest orator of their time. Upon Whitman’s death in 1892, Ingersoll delivered his eulogy. It was so well-received that it was published and can be found in Phyllis Theroux’s 1977 collection, “The Book of Eulogies.” Whitman said of his friend Bob Ingersoll, “It should not be surprising that I am drawn to Ingersoll, for he is Leaves of Grass . . . He lives, embodies, the individuality, I preach. I see in Bob the noblest specimen–American-flavored–pure out of the soil, spreading, giving, demanding light.”

While Ingersoll started no humanist organizations to carry on his beliefs, a humanist organization took up his mantle 80 years after his death. The Council on Secular Humanism supports “a nonreligious lifestance rooted in science, naturalistic philosophy, and humanist ethics.” As the Council explains: “Secular humanists reject supernatural and authoritarian beliefs. They affirm that we must take responsibility for our own lives and the communities and world in which we live. Secular humanism emphasizes reason and scientific inquiry, individual freedom and responsibility, human values and compassion, and the need for tolerance and cooperation.”

Ingersoll gave a lecture in 1897 in Boston titled “WHAT I WANT FOR CHRISTMAS.” Ingersoll’s views do not match everyone’s, and some of his thoughts will be abhorrent to many, but on the whole they harmonize nicely with the views of many Christians, for whom this time of year is especially meaningful:

“If I had the power to produce exactly what I want for next Christmas, I would have all the kings and emperors resign and allow the people to govern themselves.

“I would have all the nobility crop their titles and give their lands back to the people. I would have the Pope throw away his tiara, take off his sacred vestments, and admit that he is not acting for God — is not infallible — but is just an ordinary Italian. I would have all the cardinals, archbishops, bishops, priests and clergymen admit that they know nothing about theology, nothing about hell or heaven, nothing about the destiny of the human race, nothing about devils or ghosts, gods or angels. I would have them tell all their “flocks” to think for themselves, to be manly men and womanly women, and to do all in their power to increase the sum of human happiness.

“I would have all the professors in colleges, all the teachers in schools of every kind, including those in Sunday schools, agree that they would teach only what they know, that they would not palm off guesses as demonstrated truths.

“I would like to see all the politicians changed to statesmen, — to men who long to make their country great and free, — to men who care more for public good than private gain — men who long to be of use.

“I would like to see all the editors of papers and magazines agree to print the truth and nothing but the truth, to avoid all slander and misrepresentation, and to let the private affairs of the people alone.

“I would like to see drunkenness and prohibition both abolished.

“I would like to see corporal punishment done away with in every home, in every school, in every asylum, reformatory, and prison. Cruelty hardens and degrades, kindness reforms and ennobles.

“I would like to see the millionaires unite and form a trust for the public good.

“I would like to see a fair division of profits between capital and labor, so that the toiler could save enough to mingle a little June with the December of his life.

“I would like to see an international court established in which to settle disputes between nations, so that armies could be disbanded and the great navies allowed to rust and rot in perfect peace.

“I would like to see the whole world free — free from injustice — free from superstition.

“This will do for next Christmas. The following Christmas, I may want more.”

It seems extraordinary to me that something written 114 years ago has such resonance for today. Whatever your lifestance, and whether or not you agree with Ingersoll, I hope you have a Merry Christmas or a Happy Holiday, and keep thinking free.

© Lamar W. Hankins, Freethought San Marcos

Email Email | Print Print

--

2 thoughts on “Freethought San Marcos: A humanist looks at Christmas

  1. While you express a simplistic view of how things should be, it would be wise to understand that there are people “out there” around the world who do not agree with your Pollyanna view of how things should be. I am thankful that I am endowed by my creator with the knowledge that as long as there is Heaven and Hell, this will never be. I know that by our strength as a country, we are able to have a Merry Christmas. Once we are no longer a country of strength, we will cease to enjoy the benefits of the blessing God has bestowed on us. And yes, there is a God.

  2. This is an excellent summary of and introduction to Robert Ingersoll. I think his Christmas List for Santa Claus (!) is worthy of a modern man or woman. We, as the only Santa Claus there is must now get to work to make these things come to pass. We need Self reliance – not depencency on a sky parent – who delivers “good feelings” to some but no substance to all.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

:)